Best diet? Consumer Reports weighs in on Jenny Craig, Weight Watchers, Atkins and more

Video of the Day

Jenny Craig vs Nutrisystem in 2018
Bridging the Middle East conflict with music. More than 60 percent of U. An editorial accompanying the study in the Annals of Internal Medicine says, "Programs that help patients restrict calories with a structured approach to making healthier, real-world dietary choices, such as Weight Watchers, may fare better over the long term than programs that rely solely on prepackaged meals or supplements, but this would need to be confirmed in future studies. Nutrisystem Nutrisystem also appears to be one of the more effective commercial weight loss programs reviewed in the study. The "Walking for Weight Loss" Program.

Featured in Health

Which diet plans really pay off?

Dieters can expect to enjoy plenty of fruits and vegetables, lean meats and pasta. Weight Watchers, while offering prepackaged foods, uses the points values to allow dieters to eat anything they want while still staying within their daily allowance, so it might be a better fit for those who have favorite foods that they don't want to give up.

Dieters have to expend effort on either plan. In a Weight Watchers plan, a good deal of effort goes toward calculating points and making sure that you constantly are under your daily allowance.

A food journal may be helpful for this purpose. There are also weekly meetings and weigh-ins to attend. Jenny Craig users mostly just eat the food that is delivered to them, but they will still need to meet with their counselors, and once they leave the plan, learn more about counting calories to maintain their weight loss. News and Health Report. Jenny Craig requires an initial registration fee, followed by weekly payments for prepackaged food.

Weight Watchers gives you the option of paying for unlimited monthly meetings or paying per meeting for only the meetings you attend. You also have the option you purchase access to the online program exclusively. Video of the Day. The Diet Center Diet Plan. Free Weight Watchers Meal Plan. South Beach Diet Vs. The Dangers of Weight Watchers. Promotes a flexible eating program without any regimented eating plan or schedule. Requires use of PointsPlus under the Weight Watchers program; dieters may eat what they like as long as they do not exceed daily PointsPlus values.

Encourages whole grains, lean proteins, fruits and vegetables, and dairy. Dieters eat an average of calories per day across three meals and one snack. Female dieters eat an average of calories per day; males eat an average of calories per day. Dieters consume three meals and two snacks, plus six servings of fruits and vegetables, each day. This program centers around its female-only gyms. Program promotes strength training and cardio workouts. May also use Curves Smart , the electronic coaching system.

There is no structured plan. Dieters attending meetings will not gain much guidance in the way of fitness. Dieters using Weight Watchers Online will have access to a wealth of information to help guide their workouts. Dieters will have access to a personalized fitness plan via their counselor at the Jenny Craig center. Exercise DVDs are available with certain plans. Members of the Curves gyms may access MyCurves for community support and access to a variety of weight loss tools.

Those not interested in attending the gyms can subscribe to Curves Complete for nutrition and fitness guidance online. Weight Watchers Online is a robust program online that offers all that Weight Watchers does. Full access to the PointsPlus program, fitness guidance, community support, recipes and much more.

Members can register online to access online eTools, recipes, weight trackers, menu planners, recipes, and more. This is the only program of the four that does not have an off-line component. NutriSystem is managed completely online. Order meals, plus access tools, food and exercise diaries, the community, and more. Weight Watchers Meetings began 50 years ago, and have found great success with weekly meetings hosted by a trained leader.

As cost can vary greatly by season, promotional offer or by franchise, it is best to contact each program directly to see what a plan for you might cost. Based on a report comparing the cost to lose 30 pounds with different diet brands: Leave this field empty. The information provided within this site is strictly for the purposes of information only and is not a replacement or substitute for professional advice, doctors visit or treatment.

The provided content on this site should serve, at most, as a companion to a professional consult.

Secondary links